Scores and Comments

19.c.pr.102.754

South Florida Friends of Classical Music, Inc.

Application Details

Proposal TypeSpecific Cultural Project - Discipline-Based
Request Amount
$25,000
Total Score605.000
Average Score86.429

Panelist Scores

Panelist Excellence Impact Management Accessibility Total
Ackley Malecha Jan 32 27 15 10 84
Berry Shawn 39 22 19 10 90
Copher Daniel 37 25 17 10 89
Dwyer Kara 32 25 18 10 85
Ivey Aisha 38 24 16 9 87
Scherber Ryan 36 26 18 10 90
Wilcox Laura 35 21 14 10 80

Comments

Ackley Malecha Jan - Score: 84.000

Great international appeal and public relations via broadcast of competition.

Q funds from grant requested for website upgrade?

Evaluation and marketing plan are not clear (ie "might hire")

 

Berry Shawn - Score: 90.000
{No comments provided.}
Copher Daniel - Score: 89.000
{No comments provided.}
Dwyer Kara - Score: 85.000
{No comments provided.}
Ivey Aisha - Score: 87.000
{No comments provided.}
Scherber Ryan - Score: 90.000

Excellence:

  • The mission is missing.  This is a statement of goals and not a pithy mission statement.
  • The aims of the organization and this proposal are highly laudable, however specific and measurable objectives are absent from the proposal.  

Impact:

  • Narrative here includes important information.  It would be good to see more specifics if at all possible, possibly details from similar proposals regarding hotel stays and such.
  • More details about the outreach program would be nice here.  It sounds like a wonderful opportunity, but it is not fully articulated how such an outreach program would work.
  • The marketing plan has a great deal of detail, but it seems a bit scattered in it's presentation. It would be beneficial to see this better organized to easily glean the information.  Additionally, how large is the mailing list?  How many social media likes and follows?  These details are incredibly important in assessing reach.

Management:

  • The evaluation plan has a great deal of detail.  It would also be good to see the surveys included in the supplemental materials section as well to look over the questions.

 

Wilcox Laura - Score: 80.000
{No comments provided.}