Scores and Comments

19.c.ps.114.652

Florida Arts, Inc.

Application Details
Proposal TypeGeneral Program Support - Discipline-Based
Request Amount
$90,000
Total Score506.000
Average Score84.333

Panelist Scores

Panelist Excellence Impact Management Accessibility Total
Balog Scott 35 26 17 8 86
Betancourt Javier 40 30 10 10 90
Grundy-Lester Gabrielle 36 26 18 7 87
Hudson-Smith Suzanne 33 24 18 9 84
Suau John 28 23 15 9 75
Vickery Clare 35 25 15 9 84

Comments
Balog Scott - Score: 86.000
{No comments provided.}
Betancourt Javier - Score: 90.000

Good objectives; decent partnerships; lots of artists; proposal impact mostly economic; budget is specific with line detail; great accessibility statement with diversity; 

CONCERNS: could use more detail on art and artists; more detail on work with the schools, what are the sources for the economic impact data? $2.5 million? what is the exact estimate of outreach programs? ("many thousands"); what private donors / corporate sponsors are engaged? evaluation program could use more specificity
Grundy-Lester Gabrielle - Score: 87.000
{No comments provided.}
Hudson-Smith Suzanne - Score: 84.000
{No comments provided.}
Suau John - Score: 75.000

Goals are not differentiated from objectives.  Not a clear understanding of the difference. 

Not a clear statement of impact.  No economic or educational impact addressed.

Evaluation plan very general and not tied to specific goals or objectives.

 

Although some good methods to evaluate, but not clear on how this will evaluate objectives and goals.
Vickery Clare - Score: 84.000
It would be nice to see examples of work completed and/or presented by the organization including video. So we could see the quality of the art bring prepared and shown. The grant was kind of scant on details for the amount of money being requested. The website is nicely done.