Scores and Comments

19.c.ps.114.423

Firehouse Cultural Center, Inc.

Application Details
Proposal Type	General Program Support - Discipline-Based
Request Amount	$42,875
Total Score	517.000
Average Score	86.167

Panelist Scores

Panelist	Excellence	Impact	Management	Accessibility	Total
Balog Scott	33	27	18	9	87
Betancourt Javier	36	26	16	3	81
Grundy-Lester Gabrielle	36	27	18	10	91
Hudson-Smith Suzanne	36	25	17	10	88
Suau John	34	28	15	10	87
Vickery Clare	34	26	15	8	83

Comments
Balog Scott - Score: 87.000
Focus on marketing staff support in proposal
Betancourt Javier - Score: 81.000
good organization with lots of creative activity; marketing plan is great; excellent partnerships; very detailed timeline; good detail on demographic CONCERNS: The proposal is only for a marketing plan which is by definition not direct services, while it is clear how it integrates into the arts and culture programming of the organization a more direct proposal would help future applications; evaluation needs more specific structure; there are questions in the budget; what is the role of the tech staff; there is a line item for performing artists but unclear how employed; why is training for marketing needed? accessibility statement is perfunctory and basic; no inclusion or outreach
Grundy-Lester Gabrielle - Score: 91.000
Would be nice to see letters of support from the community in support materials.
Hudson-Smith Suzanne - Score: 88.000
{No comments provided.}
Suau John - Score: 87.000
Good Impact information Good marketing plan Evaluation does not tie into the goals and objectives. Goals and objectives are useless if they are not measured by an evaluation.
Vickery Clare - Score: 83.000
It would be nice to see cultural division grants allocated to artists who'll amplify the programming and give the media consultants content to post (versus marketing specific although that is a creative profession). It would be great as in many of these applicants to have samples of member's finished work including video of productions etc...It will be important to have that type of information to share on the new website and social media.